SO this pudding WILL NOT set with any alternative milk. it turns out really weird and is quite disappointing when you're expecting delicious pudding. I read online though that after you cook it and follow the directions you can blend it with tofu and comes out pretty good. If you google vegan pudding not setting you can find that recipe. But it won't set if you just follow the box directions with soy/almond/hemp/etc milk.
Great pudding--Use Almond Milk!
November 17, 2011 | Rachel
I made this pudding with Almond Milk and let it settle overnight in the fridge. Turned out great--friends couldn't believe a non-dairy pudding could taste so good!
October 16, 2012 | Sara
I have tried vanilla and chocolate with almond milk. Both turned out great!